Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man Essay Questions

1. According to Reid, how is the evidence for our own personal identity different from our evidence for the identity of other persons?

2. Explain Reid’s account of personal identity. Is the account compelling? Why or why not?

3. Explain the basic tenets of Lock’s account of personal identity. How does Reid criticize Locke’s account? How could Locke respond to Reid’s criticisms? Overall, which argument is more compelling? Defend your answer.